Subscribe | Renew | Give a Gift

Popular Woodworking Editors' Blog

Sign In  
# Saturday, July 28, 2007
New Lie-Nielsen Progressive-pitch Dovetail Saw

In all hand aspects of hand-tool woodworking, how you begin an operation with a hammer, plane or saw greatly influences your chance of success. Maintaining a proper strike, stroke or slice is far easier than trying to recover from a botched one.

So it makes sense that a tool should be designed to be easy to begin an operation. That’s why some hammers have cross-piens, some joinery planes have long fences and some saws have specially shaped teeth.

With saws, the simplest way to make them easier to start is to put some fine teeth at the toe of the tool and coarse teeth at the heel. You begin the cut with short strokes using the fine teeth and then lengthen your strokes to unlock the speed of the coarse teeth. And that’s exactly what Lie-Nielsen Toolworks has done with a customized version of its dovetail saw that is now available for a $10 upcharge.

This special saw with its progressive pitch begins with 16 teeth per inch at the toe and ends with 9 tpi at the heel. Otherwise, the saw is the same as the stock Lie-Nielsen dovetail saw – the teeth are filed rip and the brass back and handle are unchanged.

Thomas Lie-Nielsen loaned me a prototype of one of these saws about 18 months ago to test, and to be honest I didn’t take a liking to it at first. I’ve never had difficulty starting a dovetail saw (everyone learns this with practice) and for some reason found the progressive-pitch saw a bit harder to control than the stock Lie-Nielsen I’ve been using for years.


The fine teeth at the toe of the progressive-pitch dovetail saw.

But I kept using the progressive-pitch model, part out of stubbornness and part out of the knowledge that all freshly sharpened rip saws are a bit grabby and jerky in the cut. After a few months of use, the saw began to break in and I began to – grudgingly – see its merits.


The coarse teeth at the heel of the saw. (This photo was taken at the same magnification as the one above.)

Now it’s my favorite dovetail saw. Not because it starts easy (it does) but because it will fly through a cut thanks to the ravenous coarse teeth at the heel. Now that the saw and I understand each another, each cut goes something like this: Two short strokes at the toe to begin the kerf, followed by three long strokes along the entire toothline, followed by a short stroke or so to just touch the baseline of my joint.

These last little strokes to hit my baseline can be made anywhere on the toothline of the tool – so if I’m really close to my baseline I’ll use the fine teeth at the toe. If I have a little ways to go I’ll use the faster teeth in the middle. I started doing this out of instinct (not cleverness) and didn’t realize I was doing it at first.

This week, Thomas sent me an e-mail saying that his company is ready to start making the progressive-pitch saw for customers. The price is $135. The saw isn’t yet on the company’s web site, but if you call and ask, they will be happy to take your order.

— Christopher Schwarz


Read other entries by Christopher Schwarz
Bookmark and Share
Saturday, July 28, 2007 4:16:18 PM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)  #  Comments [2] 
# Wednesday, July 25, 2007
Belt Sander – Is It a Lost Tool?

At the AWFS show in Las Vegas (I’m sure you’ve seen the blog entries and the special AWFS page at our web site), one of the highlights was a trip to the Hard Rock Café to witness my first Delta/Porter Cable press event. What a great evening.

At the event, Delta/Porter Cable unveiled a new look and some new tools to the attendees. Some of these tools were going to be immediately available, some will be brought out during the coming year and a few were prototypes that may change drastically prior to anyone seeing the end result.

As I surveyed the tools displayed behind velvet ropes – the “look but don’t touch” directive gave the impression of a Hollywood movie-star filled event – I noticed a large number of belt sanders. The belt sander was once my most useful sanding tool, but I cannot remember that last time I used it in the shop.

As I began woodworking I would assemble my panels and when they came out of the clamps, the belt sander was the next tool used. I would flatten the panels, working at a slight angle to the grain and glue line, starting with #120-grit sandpaper then progressing through #150. Once the panel was flat and smooth, I would make a couple passes over the board using #150 and #180 grit in a random orbit sander (ROS).

That entire process got easier with the addition of a drum sander. I used #120 grit in the drum sander, but because a drum sander leaves straight-line scratches, my belt sander was still my tool of choice for the next step in preparing the panels. I used it with #150 grit to clean up those scratches before the ROS took over.

Bringing the wide-belt sander into the shop was the "kiss of death" for my once-beloved belt sander. Now I had a machine that not only sanded flat and smooth, but because the pivoting head allowed the sanding belt to oscillate back and forth, there were no more straight-line scratches. From the wide-belt sander I moved directly to the ROS to finish the sanding process.

This walk down memory lane leads me to wonder about the belt sander’s role in woodworking today. I know hand-tool folks don’t use this tool, except for possible rough grinding of nasty chisels or blades. But what about power tool woodworkers? Do you still have the belt sander in your arsenal of power tools? As new sanders are released should Popular Woodworking bring them in for review? Would those reviews be helpful? Let me know your thoughts by leaving a comment.

– Glen D. Huey


Read other entries by Glen D. Huey
Bookmark and Share
Wednesday, July 25, 2007 11:17:30 AM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)  #  Comments [24] 
# Monday, July 23, 2007
Available Now: All the Issues from 2000 on CD

The year 2000 was a turning point for Popular Woodworking magazine. In 1999 the new owners of our magazine gave us a green light to redesign the entire publication and start down the path we are on today.

That was when we started adding a significant number of stories about hand tools into our pages, blending them carefully with our power-tool coverage. We started adding top-shelf contributing writers, such as Nick Engler, Roy Underhill and Scott Phillips. And we brought on staff a new photographer and art director.

So if you like Popular Woodworking now but you didn't subscribe in 2000, we think you'll like this new CD. On it, we've put all eight issues we published in 2000 (that was when we published an annual Tool Buying Guide) in pdf format. All of the advertisements have been removed. It's just 425 pages of pure woodworking content – and completely text-searchable – for $19.96.

As a bonus, we've included on the CD a complete index of all the stories in both a spreadsheet and word processing format. Plus, we've included a bonus issue on this CD, the September 1999 issue of Popular Woodworking – that's the first issue that features our new design (and 66 more pages of content).

The 2000 issues feature a lot of great stories, here are just a few we think you'll be interested in. Or you can download a complete list of stories here:

2000IndexbyCategory.doc (234 KB)

Restoring a Handplane
Flea markets are infested with dirt-cheap old handplanes. Rick Peters shows you how to
transform a $5 piece of junk into a workhorse for your woodshop.

Borrowing a Design
If you’ve ever sat at your kitchen table with a blank sheet of paper and an equally blank
mind, let Roger Holmes show you how some pros design original pieces of furniture.

Pennsylvania Stepback
This Colonial cupboard has it all: traditional joinery, proportions and the techniques to put your woodworking skills to the test.
By Glen Huey

Should You Buy Professional Tools?
What’s the difference between $50 router and a $150 router? We take you inside to show how the things you can’t see sometimes affect the price.
By Randy Caillier

Handmade Hardware
Step inside a darkened blacksmith’s shop, where custom cabinet hardware is made almost exactly as it was 200 years ago.

Traditional Secretary
Troy Sexton’s gorgeous dropfront secretary is the culmination of a lifetime of professional woodworking experience and a brief stroke of luck at an auction.

What You Must Know About Shelving
Building great bookcases requires more planning than real skill. Learn the essential rules to constructing shelving that is stout, attractive and adaptable.

The Way Wood Works
To properly design and build a project, you need to know wood’s strengths, weaknesses and how much it’s going to move. Nick Engler shows you how to avert disaster by following three simple rules.

Shop of the Crafters Morris Chair
Without a doubt the oversized seat, reclining back and wide arms will make this chair the
most comfortable place to relax in your home.

Compound Miters for Dummies
Cutting accurate miters and compound miters is one of the most vexing problems woodworkers face. Learn to set up your table saw to cut virtually any slope.
By Nick Engler

Lathe From a Loft
The always-inventive Roy Underhill stumbled onto some discarded timbers and got the bright idea to turn them into a foot-powered lathe and scrollsaw. You can, too.
By Roy Underhill

The CD is in stock now and ready for immediate shipping. The CD works with both PCs and Macintosh computers running Adobe Reader 6.0 or later (Reader is a free program). The price is $19.96 with free shipping in the United States.

Order the Popular Woodworking 2000 CD from our store now.

— Christopher Schwarz


Read other entries by Christopher Schwarz
Bookmark and Share
Monday, July 23, 2007 2:30:19 PM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)  #  Comments [0] 
New Issue of Woodworking Magazine in Stock and Available

[description]Issue 8 of Woodworking Magazine (our sister publication) is now available in both digital and printed formats directly from us. We've shipped out the issues to our newsstand distributors  (see below to download a list of dealers that will sell it).

The staff is particularly proud of this issue. It's our biggest issue ever and we think it breaks some new ground on some important topics: workbench design, constructing tool racks and choosing a flush-cutting saw.

You have several choices as to how you can purchase this issue. It’s not complicated, but it is new, and so here is a complete explanation.

1. Buy the printed edition:
You can order a printed copy of Issue 8 directly from us through our Internet store for $8 or by calling toll-free 800-258-0929 (ask for item #PW0907). You also will be able to purchase the issue from a select number of specialty stores, including all of the Lee Valley retail stores in Canada and woodworking stores in the United States. You can download a complete list of stores arranged by state to find a location near you. The issue should be available on newsstands in early August.

Download a list of Dealers: WM_Dealers.doc (83.5 KB)

2. Buy a digital download edition:
  You can download Issue 8 from our Internet store right now for $6. The digital edition is a pdf file that has been enhanced with additional links and resources. We’ve added buttons in the issue that will call up additional related stories, video and slideshows on our web site. The pdf can be read by any computer with the free Acrobat Reader program from Adobe (most computers come loaded with this program already). Here’s how the digital download works. It’s quite easy. After you pay for the issue you will be sent an e-mail. Inside that e-mail is a link that you’ll click that will allow you to log in to our web site with a username and password. When you log in, you’ll be taken to a page that will let you download the file. It’s a large file (about 8mb), but if you have trouble downloading it, you can come back to that page as many times as you like if you encounter some sort of problem. Our connection is fast and stable, and we haven’t had anyone encounter any serious difficulty yet.

3. Buy both digital and printed editions:  You can order both the digital and printed editions of Issue 8 from our Internet store for $10. If you choose this option, you will be able to download the digital issue immediately, as described above. Plus you will be shipped the printed copy of the magazine from our warehouse in Wisconsin.

— Christopher Schwarz


Read other entries by Christopher Schwarz
Bookmark and Share
Monday, July 23, 2007 12:04:36 PM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)  #  Comments [0] 
# Friday, July 20, 2007
Exclusive Interviews with Norm Abram and Scott Phillips

Now Live. Click on either name to see our videos.

What tools would Norm Abram and Scott Phillips grab on the way out the door if their shops caught fire?

Find out next week when Popular Woodworking presents exclusive video interviews with Norm Abram and Scott Phillips. On Friday morning at the AWFS show in Las Vegas, Publisher Steve Shanesy sat down with these two woodworking icons for a round of questions no one else has ever asked and answers that might surprise you. Senior Editor Glen Huey was on the scene with our video camera and he’ll be editing the footage on the airplane ride home. By Monday or Tuesday, these will be available here on our web site.

We visited Norm’s New Yankee Workshop two summers ago, and Shanesy spent three days with Norm building Adirondack chairs, while former Managing Editor Kara Gebhart-Uhl peeked around in the corners and found out the real story about how Norm works to create the projects featured on his show. Scott is an old friend and neighbor and host of “The American Woodshop” which will start its 13th season on Aug. 11.

Both Norm and Scott were at the Delta/Porter Cable booth at the show, and graciously agreed to spend some time with us. Check back and find out what tools Norm and Scott would get first if they had to start over. Norm has influenced thousands of woodworkers, who does he look up to? What did Scott do before woodworking, and what was the most impressive thing he saw at the show?

Read more exclusive coverage and see more video coverage of the show.

— Robert W. Lang


Read other entries by Robert W. Lang
Bookmark and Share
Friday, July 20, 2007 2:29:15 PM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)  #  Comments [2] 
Riving Knives-Report from AWFS 2007



Bosch's new riving knife system on its 4100 series of table saws.

Riving Knives – Not Just for
The Europeans Anymore


Of all the new things appearing at this year’s AWSF show, the most exciting is the sudden appearance of true riving knives and sensible guard systems on a number of new table saws. The rules are changing, both literally and figuratively. Kelley Mehler, who wrote an article on European-style table saws for our August 2007 issue, lobbied and worked with Underwriter’s Laboratories in the development of new rules for table saw guards manufactured and sold in the United States. These regulations will require that guards on table saws be easily removable and replaceable, and most importantly to us, that saws be equipped with riving knives.

When we reviewed the SawStop cabinet saw in 2005, we noted that in our opinion, the riving knife was a more important safety feature than the braking system. When we took our first look at the Powermatic 2000, we were happy to see a riving knife included. This year, several more manufacturers are getting on board, in advance of the new UL regulations.

The SawStop, like airbags in your car, will provide some protection after an accident has happened. And, like airbags, braking systems that stop the saw on contact with the blade add significantly to the cost. What if there were a simple device that could be easily attached to your car that would prevent most accidents from happening in the first place? Would you want one? That doesn’t exist yet for your car, but there is a simple device that attaches to a table saw that will prevent many accidents.

About Riving Knives
So just what is a riving knife, and what does it do? There are two ways to cut yourself on a table saw. The first is to not pay attention to where your hands are and stick them into the spinning blade. The second is when part of the board comes in contact with the back part of the blade – the part that is spinning up from the saw’s table, after the cut is made. This causes the board to rise and kick back toward the operator. If your hand is on the board at that point, it can be thrown into contact with the blade before you know it. A careful worker can avoid both these situations, but it takes more skill, experience and diligence to avoid the second one.

A proper riving knife travels with the blade as it is raised, lowered of tilted, covering the area behind the back of the blade. It is close to the same thickness as the blade, so that a piece of wood can’t move into the rising saw teeth, and your hand can’t come in contact with this part of the blade. It keeps the wood tight against the fence for a few inches after the cut has been made. This is an inexpensive, effective and proactive approach to preventing accidents before they happen. Bosch, Delta, DeWalt, Grizzly, General, Jet, Powermatic, Shop Fox and Steel City are all displaying saws at AWFS equipped with riving knives that will are either now available, or will be available in the next few months.


An inside look at Jet's riving knife system.

In addition to requiring riving knives the new regulations also will require that guards can be removed and replaced in less than 20 seconds, without the use of tools. This eliminates the excuse that many of us use, that it is too much trouble to remove and replace the guard. The tool companies are taking some different approaches to this. The Powermatic and Steel City Saws have a lever that releases the guard and pawl assembly. When that is removed, the riving knife snaps in where the guard was. Grizzly’s approach is similar but instead of a lever, a nut is turned.

By far, the best systems we saw were on the Jet Exacta saw, and on inexpensive job-site saws from Bosch and DeWalt. With these systems, each part of the assembly is a separate component, held in place with a spring-loaded pin or a lever. If you want to use the guard and splitter, but remove the pawls, you can do so in just a few seconds.

I liked the Bosch and DeWalt systems the best, because of the over-blade guard, which has a clear plastic cover for each side of the blade. When lifted up, there is a detent at the top that holds the guard above the blade. If you want to make a measurement from fence to blade, or rip a narrow piece, you can do so without fighting the guard.

Here is a rundown of what we saw:

Bosch’s riving knife is available on the 4100 series of job-site saw.

Grizzly introduced its system on a 12” saw last year at the IWF show in Atlanta. This year it has put the same system on a new 10” cabinet saw (the G0651 and G0652). In addition, Grizzly has a nice 10” European-style saw (the G0623X) with riving knife and European guard with dust collection, a sliding table and a scoring blade for a bit less than a SawStop 10” cabinet saw.

Jet has a riving knife and easily removable guard on its 10” Xacta saw. Jet’s hybrid and contractor saws have an easily removable guard, but riving knives won’t be available for these in the near future.

Powermatic includes the riving knife on its PM2000 model, which has been available in this configuration since early 2006.

Steel City will introduce its riving knife and guard system on its hybrid saws, beginning around the first of 2008. This is the same saw that surprised the show with a granite top Wednesday morning. This saw will be available with either a cast iron or granite top. The company’s larger cabinet saws will incorporate these features next spring.

We are looking forward to taking all of these saws for a test-drive in our shop this fall and winter, and we salute these forward-thinking manufacturers for going ahead and including these features ahead of schedule.

— Robert W. Lang

read more reports from the 2007 AWFS show



Read other entries by Robert W. Lang
Bookmark and Share
Friday, July 20, 2007 9:57:53 AM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)  #  Comments [8] 
# Thursday, July 19, 2007
Answers to Bicycle Lathe Questions

Don Weber’s Bicycle Lathe article in the August 2007 issue (#163) has sparked a lot of interest and questions. So below, Don has provided answers to some of the repeat questions. He’s also working on a plan drawing for constructing a bicycle lathe; we’ll let you know as soon as the plan is available, and how you can get it.

Concerning shaft dimension and fittings: I used a 1" cold-rolled steel shaft procured from my local machine shop. Any 1"-diameter shaft will do; it fits a standard pillow block available from most hardware stores. The bicycle sprocket, purchased from my local bike shop, is a standard 13-tooth, single-gear sprocket. I had our local machinist turn a collet for me to thread into the fine threaded hole in the sprocket, leaving enough collar to drill and tap for a ¼” 20 set screw. You can turn your own collet from hardwood (I’ve made one from Lignnum Vitae), but steel will last longer.

The attachments for the flywheel and faceplate, or grinding wheel attachment, were 1-1/2" floor flanges with a 1" reducer. The extra reducer allowed me to drill and tap for the 1/4" 20 set screw. The floor flange does not have enough shoulder to accommodate a set screw. I had to drill out the threads in the reducer with a 1" drill on the drill press. I did this by screwing the flange and reducer to a scrap of plywood, then clamping the plywood to the drill-press table. It made holding the reducer more secure and safe. It also helped to keep the bore true to the shaft.

For other questions regarding the lathe, e-mail Don Weber (dbodger@kyblue.com) — and we'll let you know soon about plan availability.

— Megan Fitzpatrick



Bookmark and Share
Thursday, July 19, 2007 11:21:46 AM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)  #  Comments [3] 
# Tuesday, July 17, 2007
Exclusive: Steel City Will Rock Your World



In a completely inspired move, newcomers Steel City Tool Works is unveiling a line of machinery later this year that will use granite – let me repeat that – granite as a key component.

Steel City’s new hybrid 10” table saw will sport a 150-pound black granite top that is flat across its width (measured diagonally) by .001” to .002” at most. This top will never warp and never rust. It will add extra weight to reduce vibration. And it looks incredible.

We’re not talking about a piece of granite like you would find in a kitchen countertop that’s about 3/4” thick. This top is 50 mm thick (about 2”). In addition to this granite top, this new hybrid saw will feature a European-style riving knife and guard (hurrah!), a trunnion system that adds many extra pounds of cast iron mass and an improved fence system that glides over the tabletop.

Once you get over the shock of a granite-topped table saw, you’re probably thinking it’s going to be expensive. Nope. The base-model table saw with a granite top will come with 30”-long rails and a 1-3/4hp motor for $1,049 after a rebate is applied. (You also can get the saw with a cast-iron top for $999 after rebate, but for $50 the granite is the hot ticket.)

Steel City plans to release the granite-topped table saw in November or December, according to company officials.



The underside of the granite-topped 14" band saw.

In addition to adding the granite to the top of the hybrid table saw, Steel City is also putting the granite top on its new 14” band saw (other band saws from Steel City will follow suit), and a 6” jointer and 8” jointer.

But the granite on the jointers won’t be on the tops of the machines. It’s going to be the fence. I personally don’t think I’ve ever used or owned a jointer that had fence that was free from twist or bow. We put a straightedge all over the fence on the 8” granite-fenced jointer and that thing is flatter than any fence I’ve encountered. That granite fence is a huge upgrade for accuracy with jointers. The granite on the band saw and jointer should be available in the late fall, possibly as early as October.


Scott Box places a straightedge on a granite jointer fence.

The Idea for Granite

When senior editors Glen Huey and Robert Lang and I first saw the granite machines we were skeptical of the idea. It seemed like it might be fragile. But then we actually saw it. Now we want one.

So how did the company officials come up with the idea for granite? Scott Box, one of the founders of Steel City Tools, says it all started over a couple beers while the American and Chinese officials of the company were in the city of Quindao, where Steel City has a factory.

The surrounding Shandong province is known for its granite quarries, so the raw materials and skilled labor were right there.

“We’ve always been fighting cast iron,” says Box, who has worked his entire life in the woodworking machinery business. “It warps on its own. When you cut it, it’s like wood. You never know which way it’s going to go.”

When the idea of a granite-topped machine came up, it seemed like a lark. But the more they talked about it, the more it seemed like a good idea. So they picked out some black granite from a nearby mountain (about an hour away from the company’s factory) and started investigating.

The granite can be machined like cast iron on CNC machines, but it doesn’t move when you mill it.

“Cast iron we stress-relieve for six months,” Box says. “These tops have been stress relieved for 150 million years.”   

There are some minor differences in a granite top. You cannot tap it. So there are special stainless steel insets epoxied into the rock. The wing of the table saw weighs about 50 pounds so there is additional bracing below (and a micro-adjust system). And the T-slot for the miter gauge is more like a dovetailed way – with a slightly different design for the bar that keeps the gauge from tipping (though the bar is still a true 3/4” x 3/8”).

We’re impressed. We think you will be, too. Steel City Tools impressed us last year with its new offerings of tools, and this innovation proves that the company is moving fast.

— Christopher Schwarz

Read all our AWFS coverage at popularwoodworking.com/awfs


Read other entries by Christopher Schwarz
Bookmark and Share
Tuesday, July 17, 2007 10:17:55 PM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)  #  Comments [6] 
# Friday, July 13, 2007
Popular Woodworking/LumberJocks Challenge 01

LumberJocks is an online community of woodworkers that have a common thread. They enjoy sharing with one another, they appreciate one another’s work, and a good challenge doesn’t go unanswered. We know firsthand about their penchant for a challenge because Popular Woodworking, with some urging from LumberJocks members, issued a challenge. Immediately, many members were off to the shop to plan their entries, and try to goad others into revealing their ideas.

The challenge was to use the Thorsen House Table from the February 2007 (Issue #160) of Popular Woodworking as inspiration to build a project using the Greene & Greene design, while adding personal design details. We knew from the chatter on the LumberJocks web site the challenge was going to be great.

Normally the LumberJocks members judge themselves. This time, however, the Popular Woodworking editors were handed the honor. As the projects made their way onto the web site, we realized the task was not going to be easy. Then as the deadline passed, we knew we had a tough job in front of us.  

After careful scrutiny we awarded the top position. That honor goes to Neil Lamens. In the LumberJocks circle, as well as elsewhere, he is known as "Furniturologist." Lamens has a history in woodworking that began in his college days at Oswego University in New York. The woodworking bug followed him throughout his career until choices finally lead him to where he is today. Click here to read his story.

We liked the way Lamens included a drawer, and the way the pegs added to the drawer continued the Greene & Greene look in the design. He also converted the piece to a size that was more functional for his needs. By trimming the thickness of the top and breadboard ends, he lightened the overall look without sacrificing the design. If time had permitted, it would have been nice to see a bit more detail work on the table.

The honorable-mention tables were extremely nice as well. John Hoyt’s entry (he's "jackh" to the LumberJocks) was very elegant and built according to plan. If this were a reproduction contest he’d have taken the prize. We particularly liked the way he used different species of mahogany to highlight aspects of the table. The Brothers Greene would have liked it as well.

The table submitted by Mark Schroeder (aka "schroeder" to the LumberJocks) shows many of the original design ideas and he too decided to add a drawer to the table. It was a nice touch to make it concealed. We especially applaud the book-matched top and the additional work put into the shelf.

Popular Woodworking salutes all the entries. Everyone did great work. To see the entire list of entries from the LumberJocks community visit challenge 01 at their web site. But, while you’re there, check out the rest of the site. And keep an eye out for future challenges from Popular Woodworking and the LumberJocks.

Thanks to all who participated.

– Glen D. Huey


Read other entries by Glen D. Huey
Bookmark and Share
Friday, July 13, 2007 10:25:19 AM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)  #  Comments [5] 
# Tuesday, July 10, 2007
Stickley Drawers-A Close Look at Details

The great thing about writing for the blog (as opposed to for the magazine) is that there isn't any time lag for reader reaction. For the magazine, we're trying to wrap up our October issue before leaving for fabulous Las Vegas for the AWFS show. I won't know for another month and a half what anybody thinks of my work in that issue. On the other hand, I knew right away how people felt about last week's blog entry.With all the favorable comments and e-mails requesting more, I thought I should continue.

Below is an upper drawer on a Gustav Stickley #814 sideboard. I took some heat for not including drawer details in my two books of Craftsman furniture drawings. My reasoning was two-fold — the small scale necessary for the book pages would make the drawings cluttered, and most people will build drawers the way they want to anyway. Here is my take on the real thing.

In the early 1900s when this piece was made, people didn't have the same attitude that we have about dovetails. We tend to hold dovetails in awe, and for all the attention they get, you might think that this joint is the most important part of the entire piece. It's there to hold the drawer front on, and it doesn't have to be pretty to do that. Normal people will take a quick glance, notice that dovetails are there and get on with their lives. Woodworkers, on the other hand will get down on their hands and knees, pull out a magnifying glass and start an endless session of speculation and debate.

What I think is interesting is that this is a hand-cut dovetail in a piece of factory-made furniture. Dovetail machines were invented in the late 1800s and were likely commonplace by the 1920s. Stickley's factory was well-equipped for the time, but we don't have much information about specific machines or operations. I think this is an example of a hand-tool solution in a production environment. The typical Gus Stickley drawer is inset, with small, even gaps and smooth operation — even after 100 years.

The only pictures that exist of the inside of Stickley's Craftsman Workshops show cabinetmakers fitting doors and drawers to nearly completed pieces. It's easy to adopt a romantic point of view and think these guys made each piece one at a time. But that just doesn't fit with a factory setting and the volume of work produced. My best guess is that carcases and drawers were assembled up the line, and at a final workstation were fit together. The way the drawers were made and hung supports this scenario.

The little ear sticking out of the end of the drawer front gives a lot of leeway for fitting the front to the opening. A less-skilled worker could make drawers in batches, and the thin amount of end grain could be quickly trimmed without the need to shave the entire side of the drawer box. A few swipes with a block plane by a seasoned hand and the drawer is fit end to end. Likewise, the top and bottom can be shaved quickly to fit the opening. If the front is made a bit wider than the sides of the drawers, this is fast and easy.

Here is a look from below. The center guide screwed to the drawer bottom makes the adjustments to the drawer front possible without affecting how the drawer box slides or fits. This guide fits between two similar pieces on the inside of the case. This controls how the drawer moves in and out, not the fit of the drawer box to the case.

We will be posting next week from the show, here on the blog, in our e-mail newsletter (to which you can sign on the Popular Woodworking home page) and on this special page devoted to our trip to the AWFS. When we're back, we will be on the lookout for more details to share.

— Bob Lang


Read other entries by Robert W. Lang
Bookmark and Share
Tuesday, July 10, 2007 11:56:01 AM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)  #  Comments [5] 
Google Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links